Reviews for XWA-TC 23
|
|
| | I have two beefs with this otherwise perfectly enjoyable battle. In mission 3, I had to sit and wait for 10 minutes for some E/S to travel 17 clicks to a CRS to capture it and then get back. Why get back? And the last mission. Well, I made breakfast while I sat doing nothing.
|
| |
|
| | Great Battle. I don't know what people here are complaining about. Mission 6 is good because it shows that not all patrols have to have enemy craft that show up. In fact, realisticaly most of the time nothing shows up. For this reason I liked that mission. The others were top notch. Only problem was having a Chiss SSD, but Master obviously wanted to show how powerful the Chiss were and it is the only ship big enough in XWA to make that apparent.
|
| |
|
| | Good battle,mission 5th is incredible longer,more of the 55 min and this M/FRG is a terrible enemy,near of indestructible type.For the details, well, the Imperial fleet ships are in hollydays,crews watch the battle but not move a finger to help the FGs. In the first mission a Carrack cruiser or a Dreadnaught launch and launch a lot of fighters;that is complet irreal;a Carrack maximum can carrier 3 Fighters and a Dreadnaught(Modified) 2 squadrons.Mission 2:style one versus all the world;Mission 4:this Corvette is really a very good craft; not problem to fight all type of crafts with.In some missions,specially the convoy mission, the utilisation of MAG torpedos is fundamental.Well done battle.
|
| |
|
| | An enjoyable battle. Well thought out mission design and a coherent plot. Good use of difficulty settings. There were a few points where we were just sitting around and waiting (all of mission 6, for example).
|
| |
|
| | I would've liked it a bit more if my own capital ships did a bit more than sit there and look pretty
|
| |
|
| | Bah, you're all too picky. I liked the last mission. After flying several 30+ minute missions, you do a quick sweep in mission 6 and are delighted to find that, yes- you have just finished another EH battle. Well done. The YT rocks and is a blast to fly.
|
| |
|
| | Excellent battle, good plot, missions are entertaining, and not too hard, a good break from flying missions with millions of fighters vs. a little T/A. I loved it
|
| |
|
| | Ok battle, not too hard. Some nice plots and ideas. Wingmen would be nice for some of the missions. The last mission is good in the sense that it was what a 'real' mission might be like - but it has no place in a battle someone has to play!
|
| |
|
| | The best battle I've ever played!!! First two missions aren't too exciting, but the 3rd(Attack on a convoy) and the two last are great!
|
| |
|
| | This was a cool battle. A little disappointed with the last mission, but better than nothing. Not too much protecting which I like.
|
| |
|
| | Well, it was good. Not excellent, as I must agree with most of the other reviews. The last missions could have been deleted altogether as it has no purpose flying it. The mission before that bothered me a bit as well, as I can't imagine 2 ISDs and 4 VSD assaulting an almost harmless base, only launching 4 T/As and 12 T/Ds and then just sit there and watch. Taking down all cap ships and the base has the player flying back to the ISD getting reloads all over again. It tended to get boring. After finally taking down the base, you think it's all over, only to see there's one more mission, which you can complete by launching and just sitting there. The battle was well constructed, no bugs or construction errors, good story, but it is a shame the waiting and repetitive flying during the last missions made it go downhill. Therefore, I give it a 3.
|
| |
|
| | This is a great battle if you have some time and are pretty good at XWA. Even someone who is lacking in XWA skills, such as me, will have a good time with this. It’s got a great plot, some fun missions, and isn’t too frustrating. I really wish they’d avoid making me kill capital ships in a T/A in XWA though, as it gets too hard. Also, I don’t like inspection type recon missions. They all feel the same and I hate them all, just leave them out thank you. Other than that, I really recommend this battle. Go fly it if you have XWA. I give it a 4.60 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)
|
| |
|
| | This is the best battle I've ever played!!! The only problem I found was the last mission. It didn't tie in with the rest of the battle and it was boring. Regardless of that I give it a 5. Great Job Master!!!
|
| |
|
| | Good battle overall, last mission didnt really tie in with the rest, but overall lots of dog fighting fun.
|
| |
|
| | Great missions, EXCELLENT briefs/debriefs, and very consistent! Keep up the good work!
|
| |
|
| | Great Battle the missions were excellently strung together and the story was good as well. The last mission wasa bit slow but the rest makes up for it.
|
| |
|
| | Good battle. Not to boring or stupid, or hard. The plot was good (anything with Thrawn is). Although the long wait for the CRS to be captured was annoying. I'm very disturbed that Black Sun could get their hands on a Star Destroyer, and, when did the Chiss ever have an SSD?
|
| |
|
| | Very good battle, I like battles that make me fly the mission real fast to continue reading the plot-line. This battle did that very effectively.
|
| |
|
| | Good battle. Other than having to sit and wait forever when capturing the CRL, and the slow last mission, great battle, bug free, and pretty fun. Good Job, Master!
|
| |
|
| | Well its my battle and my first battle so i get to give it a 5 :) The whole point of the last mission was a reference to The Hand Of Thrawn books by Zahn, for those who have read it Thrawn had a base on that planet run by the Chiss, anyway, who's going to stand a chance against the fleet they had :P Its in my list, dont worry it will happen :)
|
| |
|
| | Very good battle ! One of the Best TC-XWA ones out there. The last mission kinda slows things down , but I am still looking foward to the sequel (ahem , nudge nudge MR. Creator )
|
| |
|
| | Excellent battle and plotline, truely a definite fly for XWA fans out there. Why the 4? The last mission should had been the first mission of the sequal...
|
| |
|
| | Good battle with good debriefings. Too bad the last mission ruins the pace of the battle.
|
| |
