Reviews for XWA-TC 14
|
|
| | Although it was interesting to follow the story, I must say that fighting such capships while the SSD is here idling is really UNrealistic. Fortunately I found a quite stupid way to make the ssd fire at ESC and CRV : draw the XWs he targets around the capships :p. Anyway I liked piloting with old fighters, very refreshing compared to T/Ds
|
| |
|
| | You know whats not fun? Takin out an ESC and a M/CRV by yourself while your superstar destroyer hovers above you doing nothing. Stuff liek this ruined this battle, no matter how 'realistic' the plot was
|
| |
|
| | Although an enjoyable battle to fly (at certain points), I was most unhappy with the second mission. The ISD Devestator did not have the aid of another ISD and a Interdictor when chasing the Tanitve IV. The Tantive IV would not need an Interdictor to pull it out of hypersapce because Princess Leia wanted to pick up Obi-wan, so she had to stop over Tatooine, nor would the Devestator need to have an Interdictor keep the Tantive IV from jumping into hyperspace because Tatooine's own gravity shadow would prevent such a jump. I find the lack of continuity disturbing.
|
| |
|
| | I don't give 5's lightly. This battle was one of the best I have ever seen. I like it's realism to ROTJ. I hope that these creators create some other history battles like for the SSD avenger or the soverign.
|
| |
|
| | Well, this battle was good, apart from the fact that it often places the player solo against a cap ship (or more in the last mission). A problem in mission 3 has been mentioned before: the Immortal shoots below the A/FRG. This is nasty as I had several occasions where the A/FRG single-handedly destroyed the Immortal. Maybe having the Immortal target a different component of the A/FRG would help. A few touches here and there and some balancing would definately help.
|
| |
|
| | Wonderful! I loved this battle. Good work, RW!
|
| |
|
| | Yay ! really nice battle ! insanely hard sometime, but fun...
|
| |
|
| | Very nice battle, the good old fighters were a welcome sight and the debriefing were actually something worth reading. Only thing I didn't like was that certain parts were if not, almost immpossibly hard on a higher level setting with your wingmen being obliterated in their unshielded craft. Anyway I still enjoyed it immensly.
|
| |
|
| | Totaly cool mission that was very fun to play Would be nice for a history of the imortal series me thinks as this is a must play battle for Star wars fans Well done do some more :)
|
| |
|
| | This battle was great! The history leson was good and the debrefings and missions were realy intersting. I only gave this a 4 because the last 2 or 3 missions were completly insane! Putting an unshielded fighter against an A/FRG is unfair! And for some reason I couldn't destroy any components on enemy cap ships ie. Shield Gens. and turbo lasers, So I had to come up from behind and blow out the engines till the ships were destroyed or let the Imortal try to take them on!
|
| |
|
| | very nice mission! the "debriefings" were also great.
|
| |
|
| | Whoever made this battles needs his head examined! Why would you put a pilot in an unshielded craft!? Because it is a lot of fun. A lot of research went into this mission to make it historically accurate, and the debriefings worked well. It is not easy, but it is definitely worth it.
|
| |
|
| | Very Cool battle! I had to fly every mission about 15 times to complete in Hard but worth it! Amazing! Specially dificult if you sent all your wingmans home! eheheh!
|
| |
|
| | A good battle! I forgot how hard it is to be in a unsheilded craft in XWA... The only reason I didn't give it 5 is because in the mission where a rebel A/FRG hypers in, the ISD targets below the actual ship. This isn't a problem with the mission, just XWA itself, but it makes it very difficult to take out a A/FRG in a unsheilded T/I.
|
| |
|
| | Great historical Reconstruction of ISD Immortal Story. A bit hard sometimes because you fly old crafts
|
| |
|
| | How about making a battle everyone can play, not just the elite
|
| |
|
| | Yeah, this was pretty challenging, but unfortunately it often forces the player to solo enemy capships -- not at all a good thing in XWA. In two missions an A/FRG tears up the Immortal (?) and in the last mission the SSD seemed to do jack diddly against the remaining enemy capships (!). Adjust/rebalance those parts and I'll give it a 4.
|
| |
|
| | Exciting Battle but a lot too hard so only 2 points.
|
| |
|
| | This battle has a great story. The briefings and debriefings were excellent. Unfortunately, mission 3 ruined it for me. Being penalized for losing your wingmen, having any capital ship or station kills stolen by the Immortal, intelligence of the Immortal and A/FRG J'Ther is way out of balance. The J'Ther's Ace AI let's it waste everything, while the Immortal with Officer AI can't hit the broadside of a barn. Much weeping and gnashing of teeth on account of that.
|
| |
